Does it matter calculating the total float from the start dates or finish dates in P6?

We were taught that the total float is the amount of time that the activity can be delayed without affecting the overall project duration.

And the calculation of the total float is the difference between the late dates and the early dates.

Either the Late Start – Early Start or Late finish – Early Finish. Both should give the same results.

But in P6 you have the option to use start dates or the finish dates in calculating the float.

Figure (1) – Shows P6 settings for float calculations

So, does it matter? Or does it give different results?

The Answer to this question is yes, it does matter in two cases.

1 – Using the WBS summary activity

2 – Using the level of effort activity

In order to know the difference, we must know how both type of activities calculate their early and late dates.

The WBS summary:

The late finish date = The latest late finish date of the activities in the WBS group. The early finish date = The latest early finish date of the activities in the WBS group.

The late start = The earliest late start date of the activities in the WBS group. The early start date = The earliest early start date of the activities in the WBS group.

So in the following example:

Does it matter calculating the total float from the start dates or finish dates in P6-1

Figure 2 – WBS summary example

Activity A1050, is a WBS summary activity has early start of activity D and late start of activity E, Early finish of Activity E and late finish of activity E.

So if the total float is calculated based on the finish date, the total float of the WBS summary activity would be zero as shown in the figure 2.

But if the settings are changed to calculate the float based on the start date the float of this activity would be 5 days as shown in the figure below.

Does it matter calculating the total float from the start dates or finish dates in P6-2

Figure 3- WBS summary float calculations based on start dates

The Level of effort activity:

The late finish date = The latest late finish date of the successor activities. The early finish date = The latest early finish date of the successor activities.

The late start = The earliest late start date of the Predecessor activities. The early start date = The earliest early start date of the Predecessor activities.

So in the following example:

Does it matter calculating the total float from the start dates or finish dates in P6-3

Figure 4 – Level of effort example

Activity A1060, is a level of effort activity has early start of activity B and late start of activity B, Early finish of Activity E and late finish of activity E.

So if the total float is calculated based on the finish date, the total float of the level of effort activity would be zero as shown in the figure 4.

But if the settings are changed to calculate the float based on the start date the float of this activity would be 3 days as shown in the figure below.

Does it matter calculating the total float from the start dates or finish dates in P6-4

Figure 5- level of effort float calculations based on start dates

So you have to consider the float calculation method for these types of activities either by:

1- Finish dates
2 – Start dates
3- Minimum of both

Source : https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/does-matter-calculating-total-float-from-start-dates-assem

 

 

 

Advertisements

Author: Khuong Do

Khuong Do is a Project Planner in Civil, Transportation and Oil & Gas Industry. He has worked as a Primavera Consultant Specialist since 2006 . He holds a Civil Engineering degree and a Bachelor of Information Management System. Now he is working in Petronas RAPID project, one of the biggest Refinery and Petrochemical complex, in Pengerang – Malaysia.

3 thoughts on “Does it matter calculating the total float from the start dates or finish dates in P6?”

  1. Thanks Khuong for such a in depth explanation.
    But still what is not coming out of the post is how does the selection on any of the option affects the overall schedule ??
    And which option do you prefer ??

    Once again thanks for sharing your learning and experience.

    Like

    1. Hi.
      It does not affect the overall schedule.
      It just affect Total Float so it may decide what is the critical path.
      In my schedule WBS Summary and Level of effort is rarely critical activities. So the option does not matter for me.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Advertisements